The Atlanta Gleaner.

Legal News

Edited By George Washington

(Testing in progress)

George Washington Statue at Federal Hall

Brownv.State

CourtSupreme Court of Georgia
Docket No.S12G1287
DecidedOctober 21, 2013
Reporter293 Ga. 787; 750 S.E.2d 148; 2013 Fulton County D. Rep. 3229; 2013 WL 5708015; 2013 Ga. LEXIS 862
JudgesSupreme Court of Georgia
Tags
CriminalCriminal ProcedureConstitutional LawFourth AmendmentSearch and SeizureTraffic StopMotion to SuppressStandard of ReviewReversal
Case Summary

Douglas Wayne Brown was stopped at a Cobb County traffic-safety checkpoint and later charged with driving under the influence, drug offenses, obstruction, and attempting to remove a weapon from an officer. The trial court suppressed his statements and other evidence, finding that the sergeant implemented the checkpoint as a field officer rather than deciding in advance as a supervisor and that the checkpoint was inadequately staffed. The Court of Appeals reversed after applying de novo review. The Georgia Supreme Court reversed the appellate judgment and reinstated suppression. It held that a checkpoint must satisfy two distinct Fourth Amendment safeguards: its program must have an appropriate primary purpose other than general crime control, and the particular checkpoint must be implemented in advance by supervisory personnel rather than an officer acting in the field. The State failed to prove the second requirement because testimony about when the checkpoint was planned was disputed, undocumented, and reasonably subject to the trial court’s credibility determination. The Court rejected understaffing as an independent constitutional violation, while recognizing that staffing could bear on whether the checkpoint was lawfully planned and operated. The judgment was reversed, and the trial court’s suppression ruling stood.

Opinion

Loading published copy…

The Far Side