Florida prisoner Wendall Hall alleged that officers sprayed him with chemical agent in retaliation for grievances and in violation of the Eighth Amendment, while the prison disciplinary process accused him of tampering with a sprinkler. The Eleventh Circuit held that Heck did not require dismissal of every claim because Hall could replead an “I did it, but the force was excessive” theory that would not invalidate the disciplinary finding. It vacated dismissal of the claims against Officers Watson and Wright and remanded to allow repleading, while affirming the jury’s verdict for Lieutenant Merola.