Statev.Brantley
CourtSupreme Court of Georgia
Docket No.S25A0208
DecidedApril 8, 2025
Reporter321 Ga. 370; 914 S.E.2d 807; 2025 Ga. LEXIS 77; 2025 LX 32397
JudgesPeterson, C.J.; Warren, P.J., and Bethel, Ellington, McMillian, LaGrua, Colvin, and Pinson, JJ., concurring.
Tags
CriminalState AppealJail CallsRight to PrivacyEqual ProtectionMotion in LimineSuppression of EvidenceTales From the CryptMurder & MayhemBodies, Burials & Blood EvidenceBehind Bars
Case Summary
The State appealed a pretrial order excluding three incriminating, recorded jail calls Barron Brantley made to other inmates while awaiting trial for the rape and murder of Alexis Crawford; an automated message warned that calls were monitored and recorded. The Supreme Court of Georgia held that the State could appeal the exclusion order, Brantley had no reasonable expectation of privacy in non-attorney calls made after the warning, and he was not similarly situated to people outside jail for equal-protection purposes. Because jail-call monitoring served a rational security purpose, the Court reversed the suppression order.
Opinion
Loading published copy…

